Centre
de la Recherche Scientifique de Dersim et Koçgiri
Dr Ali KILIC
Paris le 14 09 2009
ON THE ENVIRONMENTAL
MINERALOGY
AND
ON THE ECOLOGICAL GENOCIDE
This research is dedicated to Professor Sir Ezize CEWO
the Sacred Valley of Munzur in Dersim
When
the Academy of Sciences
organized the symposium on the ENVIRONMENTAL MINERALOGY
the Sacred Valley of Munzur will disappear. It is an ecological
and cultural genocide before the world public opinion. It
is a violation of international law. This practice of the
imperial Turkish government is opposed to the Final Declaration
of the United Nations Conference on Environment and the Kyoto
Protocol to the Convention for the protection of national
and international protection of cultural and natural heritage.
Because we believe that degradation or loss of property of
cultural and natural heritage constitutes a harmful impoverishment
of the heritage of all peoples of the world, and the protection
of this heritage at the national level often remains incomplete
because of the scale means it requires and of the insufficient
economic, scientific and technical services of the country
on whose territory the property to safeguard. Because the
Constitution provides that the Organization will maintain,
increase and diffuse knowledge by assuring the conservation
and protection of heritage, and recommending to the nations
concerned the necessary international conventions because
and conventions, recommendations and resolutions in support
of existing cultural and natural property demonstrate the
importance, for all peoples of the world, of safeguarding
this unique and irreplaceable property, to whatever people
they belong. So the Turkish colonialists have no right to
remove a natural civilization of 42 million years. It is an
ecological crime of genocide which my country has undergone.
Under the Convention on the Conservation of European Wildlife
and Natural Habitats of Europe, it is unacceptable that the
Turkish colonial state violates the convention that "This
Convention aims to ensure the conservation of flora and fauna
and their habitats, including species and habitats whose conservation
requires the cooperation of several States, and to promote
such cooperation. Particular attention is given to species,
including migratory species, endangered and vulnerable "while
with the construction of eight dams on the sacred river of
my country in 1817 species will disappear. That this practice
is not consistent with the "Convention on the Conservation
of European Wildlife and Natural Habitats of Europe, adopted
at Berne, September 19, 1979.
The fauna and flora are a natural heritage of major interest to be preserved
and transmitted to future generations. Beyond the national
emergency, the parties to the agreement believe that cooperation
at European level must be implemented.
The Convention aims to promote cooperation between the signatory
states to ensure the conservation of flora and fauna and their
natural habitats and protect endangered migratory species
extinction. " Moreover, the Bern Convention of 1982 "aims
to ensure the conservation of flora and fauna and their natural
habitat. It pays special attention to species (even migratory)
endangered and vulnerable in the annexes. The Parties undertake
to take all appropriate measures for the conservation of flora
and fauna especially in the development of national policy
planning and development, and in the fight against pollution,
this objective be taken into consideration. The Parties shall
also encourage education and dissemination of general information
regarding the need to conserve wild natural heritage.
"
This practice of colonialist Turkish state is opposed to the
Convention on Biological Diversity that "biological diversity
and value diversity and its components on the environmental,
genetic, social, economic, scientific, educational Cultural,
recreational and aesthetic, and also that where there is a
threat of significant reduction or loss of biological diversity,
lack of full scientific certainty should not be invoked as
a reason for postponing measures to enable avoid the hazard
or mitigate its effects, and further that the conservation
of biodiversity requires essentially in situ conservation
of ecosystems and natural habitats and the maintenance and
recovery of viable populations of species in their natural
environment . Under the Convention "a large number of
local communities and indigenous people close and traditional
dependence on biological resources embodying tradition and
the desirability of sharing equitably benefits arising from
the use of knowledge, innovations and practices relevant to
the conservation of biodiversity and sustainable use of its
components "The colonial policy of Turkey in the historical
heritage of Dersim is a negation of international law and
the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. As to the Convention
for the Safeguarding of the architectural heritage because
of the archaeological heritage is essential for knowledge
of past civilizations, the responsibility for protecting the
archaeological heritage should rest not only the State directly
concerned but also the all the European countries to reduce
the risk of degradation and promote conservation by encouraging
exchanges of experts and experience, so the purpose of this
Convention (Revised) is to protect the archaeological heritage
as a source of European collective memory and as an instrument
of historical and scientific study. As are included in the
archaeological structures, buildings, groups of buildings,
developed sites, moveable objects, monuments of other kinds
as well as their context, whether situated on land or under
water. Finally unfairly Department Dersim disappear with the
sacred river Munzur and heritage. International instruments
relating to the preservation of cultural heritage stipulate
a system of cultural references is essential to the development
of a nation and the people as a whole, benefits from the preservation
of cultural heritage of every society. These
instruments relating to the preservation
of cultural heritage ranging from protection of architectural
heritage to the underwater life through heritage protection
in wartime. The folklore is part of the universal heritage
of humanity, it is a powerful means of bringing together different
peoples and social groups and of asserting their identity
culturelleLe colonialist government of Turkey has not fulfilled the proposed
resolution European Parliament has called "the Turkish
government to apply European standards in the case of projects
with significant impacts, such as construction of dams in
the valley Munzur, Allianoi dam, construction of the Ilisu
Dam and the gold mining in Bergama and other regions which threaten
both the historical and unique sites and precious invites
the Turkish government to make reference to Community legislation
in the context of developing regional development projects
"
Dersim
has stood for centuries to foreign invasions and has always
managed to keep a sort of "independence". This situation
has persisted sixteen times under the Ottoman occupation and
armed resistance lasted from 1908 to 1938 during the first
two decades of the new Turkish Republic was proclaimed in
1923 has committed genocide physical. After founding of Turkey, Atatürk had one last thing to
do "civilize Dersim". We understand better the nature
of this "mission of civilization" through his speech
before the Turkish Grand National Assembly: "Dersim is
a tumor to the Government of the Republic. Whatever the price,
this tumor must be removed through a final transaction said
the "Eternal Leader" of Turkey. Everything happens very quickly:
In 1935 a new law, it prohibits not only the use
of the name of Dersim Genocide, but also with the people of
Dersim been. and they renamed the region. The new name is
not without irony: Tunceli is to say the "hand bronze"
in Turkish. After prepared, the Turkish army began moving
in 1937 to "the land of the oak," Dersim. The resistance
leaders were arrested and then executed November 15 in 1937 thirty minuite when the arrival of
Mustafa Kemal in El Azis' age of 81, despite the law prohibiting
the execution of a person having such an age. The operation
lasted a total of two years and provides a tragic outcome
for the region: 170 000 deaths and thousands of people deported
to the west of Anatolia to facilitate their assimilation.
It was the only time the Dersim mountains are considered sacred
by the locals have forsaken their people to their fate. Thus
they tasted defeat. At the heart of the region is the chain
of mountains Munzur whose highest peak reaches an altitude
of 3462 meters. The river which crosses the
region bears the same name. Dersim presents a unique bio-diversity.
Considering the wealth of the region, December 21, 1971 the
Turkish state says the River Valley Munzur 'first national park of Turkey and he is currently the largest
in the country. The valley has a length of 80 kilometers. With Munzur Mountains is home to 1518 plant species
of which 227 exist in Turkey and 43 only in the valley Munzur.
The natural wealth of the region is comparable to that of
an entire country .. In the Valley and on the chain of mountains
Munzur we also find a rich fauna. There are animals endangered
as the brown bear, wild cat, wild sheep, mountain goat horns
fangs, in the river there are trout whose particularity is
to have red scales.
Dersim
region is certainly a very rich, but wealth did not put away
a potential disaster. The region is this time threatened with
ecological disaster. For the Turkish state plans to build
in the Valley Munzur eight dams and hydroelectric plants.
What can the construction of these dams in the region? They
provide 0.97% of total electricity production of Turkey. What are the consequences? First,
84 villages will be submerged under water and dams will cause
irreparable damage to the region that has already lost much
of its population because of the depopulation policy practiced
by the Turkish state during its war against the Kurdish guerrillas
which intensified in the 1990s. Secondly, the region will
be divided into two and thus lose its geographical unity;
the risk of creating many economic and cultural. Thirdly,
the drastic climate changes occur and the endemic plants,
rare animals lose their habitat, then disappear. Finally,
the Valley Munzur which was formed 42 million years, according
to experts, will be completely destroyed. According to expert
opinion a dam has an average life of 70 years and after this
period we will be left in ruins in place of the heavenly beauty
of the valley.
The symposium of the Academy of Sciences on the ENVIRONMENTAL MINERALOGY was
organized by the Scientific Committee composed by scholars
and academicians following 14 and September 15 in Paris
the Scientific Committee composed
by
Gordon E. Brown, Jr., Stanford University
Georges
Calas, Université Pierre et Marie Curie, Paris
Jean
Dercourt, Secrétaire perpétuel de l'Académie des sciences,
Paris
Adrien
Herbillon, Université catholique de Louvain-la-Neuve
Zdenek
Johan, de l'Académie des sciences, Orléans
Ghislain
de Marsily, de l'Académie des sciences, Paris
Georges Pédro, de l'Académie des
sciences, de l’Académie d’agriculture de France,
On the scientific question of the "geosphere"
has many definitions. Some authors extend from the upper atmosphere
to the center of the lithosphere! The physical world, the
universe, all things and beings, the reality: The wonders
of nature. Set of forces or higher principle, regarded as
the origin of things in the world, its organization: Nothing
is lost, nothing is created, it is a law of nature. All principles,
forces, particularly of life, as opposed to the action of
the man she had lost confidence in the nature and doctors.
Philosophy state of nature situation that would have found
the human society, such as before when the men, while living
together, would have created no common institution and, thus,
would have been no political authority . (The state of nature
is a commonplace of political philosophy of the seventeenth
and eighteenth century idea of nature, idea behind the organization
of the cosmos, as for Aristotle, or that a particular being.
The apprehension of nature as a creative power uncreated,
impersonal sovereign and is probably the first to be imposed
on men, when they had to continuously measure the "natural
elements". In any case, since the sixth century BC flourished
in Greece, treaties Peri phuseos ( "From Nature"):
Anaximander, Anaxagoras, Parmenides of Elea, Heraclitus, and
Empedocles and Epicurus have to turn physis ride called the
infinite and unchanging principle of all things finite and
perishable.
It is Aristotle who developed the further systematization
of the idea of nature in a cosmology that was to rule unchallenged
until the advent of Galileo's physics, and especially that
of Newton. The Greek word physis, which
we translate as "nature" (Latin nasci, natus "born,"
born ") and has given French" physical "has
the same root as" fetus "and comes from the verb
phuein , which means "grow", "push", "grow"
by saying physis, Aristotle said, it feels like a push perennial
growth. Nature is indeed the cause immanent "has in itself
the principle of its movement. And, says Aristotle, "the
god and nature do nothing in vain."
Nature is composed of four simple elements:
water, air, earth, fire. In the center is the earth (severe
absolute dry) at the periphery, fire (dry and light absolute)
and in the meantime, air (light on and wet) and water (wet
and severe relative) . The man is a mixture composed of four
elements, called to join their "natural places in the
cosmos: geosphere (land), hydrosphere (water), atmosphere
(air), pyrosphere (fire). Einstein did not hide his admiration
for this ancient cosmology qualitative, which traces remain
vivid in our language and our attitudes, as shown by Gaston
Bachelard.
Heir of Democritus and Epicurus, Lucretius gives the
Latin to turn in his poem De rerum natura image of
a goddess "free, unencumbered by great masters, self-governing
his empire without coercion and without the aid of gods. This
idea of nature, perpetual scene of generations and corruptions,
where nothing comes from nothing but everything is transformed,
influenced all the "systems of nature" pantheistic
materialists and atheists.
In my thesis
in Greco Roman philology, in 1973 I analyzed the materialist
conception of the soul from Lucretius, I have studied the
report of the physical and Aristote Epicurean physics that
underlies the design of the world of Lucretius. The declination
of the atom and the qualities of the atom was indivisible
principles and elements indivisible dialectically.
[2]
I think
the ideas of Lucretius on the mount Etna volcano are very
accurate and contemporary. It is a scientific and philosophical
observation. See the comments of the Latin poet and philosopher
Lucretius
“Who among us
is surprised that a patient feels in his body burning with
fever or its members in the pain of any other ailment? Suppose
that the foot swells suddenly a sharp pain or seize the teeth,
attacks the eyes, or the sacred fire broke do, wandering throughout
the body, burns all parties that reached and seizes the body
it is clear that the cause is in the multitude of existing
principles, the earth and the sky of our world are in themselves
enough morbid elements to enable him to train sickness of
appalling proportions. So surely as heaven and earth can receive
665 infinite elements capable enough to suddenly shake the
earth, land and sea travel in fast eddies, to fill 1'Etna
lights, d ' light the fire in the sky. Yes, the sky itself
can catch fire, take the celestial fire, like rain falling
storm with more violence when are assembled in more somewhere
elements of water.
But it is huge, the fire blazing Etna!
Without doubt, but is there a river that appears great who
has never seen more? And of the same tree, so a man in all
things, what we've seen bigger, they imagine vast. Yet all
this, with heaven and earth and sea, is nothing compared to
the total mass of the great whole. Now however, I will explain
how the flame suddenly angry burst of 680 large furnaces of
Etna. First the whole mountain is hollow and almost all made
of granite caves. In all there are air, wind. The wind from
the air stirred and shaken. When it has warmed and that it
has infuriated all blazing around him, rocks and earth, and
he has brought forth rapid jets of fire, then stands and takes
his momentum straight through gorges of the volcano. It can
then l) orter off the flame, garlic disperse far cendrc, roll
the black smoke swirling in while throwing stones enormously
heavy, can you doubt that all this has its cause in the power
of a raging wind? On the other hand, the sea bathing the foot
of the mountain on a wide range, including wind and the waves
turn the reform. Now from the edge of the sea caves of the
mountain gorge extending up inside the volcano. Through it
pass the winds when the sea receded, it is necessary, and
it obviously, and that is where they direct their blows towards
the top, then they escape blowing flames, throwing stones
and raising clouds of sand. At the top of the mountain, in
fact, are the craters is the name given them by the locals,
the rest of us call them Gorges and mouth. There are still
many phenomena for which he would not propose a single cause,
but the various causes proposed one is true, so if, for example,
you see at some distance a man lying unconscious on the ground,
c ' is by listing all probable causes of death that you tell
the true. In fact, you can not decide if he has perished by
the sword, by cold, by illness or perhaps by poison, but only
one of these causes is due to his accident, is our certainty.
This is in
many subjects the right way. The Nile swells in the summer
and then overflows into the valley itself, which bathes the
whole of Egypt,
he alone of all rivers in this plan. It I'Egypte watered regularly
during the full heat, probably because in this season Etesian
prevailing winds, north winds are the fly at the mouth of
the river and their breath, taking him down, delaying its
waters, them back in his bed height and forces them to stop.
For it is certain that these winds blow in the opposite direction
of the river, as they arrive constellations icy pole. And
contrary to him, he comes from the torrid zone where soils
1'Auster; among the races of men in black complexion sunburned,
Giordano Bruno (1548-1600) was born in Nola near Naples where his father was a humble
soldier. After studying theology and philosophy, he entered
the Dominican order. He quickly noted by his rebellious spirit,
and, knowing himself suspected of heresy, he must leave Italy. It is found in so many universities
and royal courts across Europe (For
example, he teaches at the College de France). His most striking
feature is the banquet of ashes where there is a vindication
of Copernicus ( "It shows how Copernicus is worthy of
our praise") and a critique of Aristotle. It goes beyond
Copernicus and declares that:
the mass of the universe is infinite and that it is futile
to seek the center
or the circumference of the universal world. He then states
that: heaven of the fixed [the sky and its stars] 's not a
sky where the bodies we see shining would all laugh the same
distance from the center, some seem close at hand, which are
more distant from each other they can not be one and the other
of the Sun and Earth. It endangers arguing that there are
other suns and other land where life exists. He aggravated
his case by denying transubstantiation [3] . the virginity of Mary and the Trinity, and by resorting
to magical practices. After a trial lasting seven years, he
was burned alive February 17, 1600
Unlike Galileo, G. Bruno has not recanted, and he told his
judges, December 21, 1599 "I do not repent, and there
is not repentance. There is no material on which to repent,
and do not know on what I have to repent by the principle
of inertia
Giordano Bruno almost borders on inertia. He understands that
the motion of the earth over didn't observable effect on the
movements of its inhabitants that the uniform motion of a
ship does on those objects located inside a cabin. It is therefore
aware that the movement is that from a mechanical system and
a place (that is to say a point) can belong to two or more
systems without prejudice to the movement of objects in it
found (De infinito, one iverso e Mondi, 1584). But unlike
Galileo, he did not press the descriptive power of mathematics,
much less operating power, which will tell Kepler 'unfortunate
Giordano Bruno
Galileo's contribution is immense. He is the founder of mechanics,
general science movement. As Whitehead says: nor would he
not been without Newton Galileo, and it is just ironic that
he would not have by Galilee without Newton. He adds: Galileo represents
an assault Newton victory.
Galileo can be considered the father of modern science because
it does as a criterion of truth that experience and careful
reflection. It combines the use of mathematics in a way which
guarantees the objectivity. He puts the point very clearly
in it Saggiatore:
The philosophy [that is to say science] is written in this
great book which stands continuously open before our eyes,
the universe, and which can be understood if one has previously
learned to understand language and know the characters used
to write it. This book is written in mathematical language
its characters are triangles, circles and other geometric
figures without which means it is impossible to understand
a single word humanely and without which we do wander in vain
a dark labyrinth.
In 1616, the humanist Giulio Cesare Vanini
published his speech on the secrets of nature, queen and goddess
of mortal brought before an ecclesiastical court, he maintained
that "God manifests itself at every moment, more than
a few miracles often challenged by this great miracle undeniable,
relentless and always new that we call nature. This statement,
considered impious, condemning him to the stake, and he was
burned at Toulouse February 9, 1619 at the age of
thirty-four.
Observe, measure and model our land to
better understand, manage and teach, summarizes the vision
of Sciences Terre. His scientific approach designs the geosciences
as a whole, since the earth's surface to depths of Earth internal,
and this at all scales in time or space. The multidisciplinary
aspect of research is highly developed to address the major
issues raised by the study of the dynamics of Earth's internal
structure and evolution of planets, the dynamics of the natural
environment and the impact of human activities, modeling,
prediction and management of natural disasters, earthquakes
and volcanic eruptions.
Basically, Earth is a natural multiscale complex which we
seek to understand the dynamics. Scientists are particularly
interested in following items: Dynamic cooling of the Earth,
convection in the mantle, the core dynamics of volcanic eruptions,
magmatic systems .. scientific structures were built with
the aim of understanding the inner workings of the Earth's
core to its surface, using the methods of physics and chemistry,
the tools of mathematics and computer science. The Earth is
a complex, heterogeneous and range of time scales (from seconds
to billions of years) and space (nanometers to tens of thousands
of kilometers) is a research area very special. Without doubt
the field and observation of particular importance and collaborations
with specialists from the atmosphere, ocean and climate, and
more recently the life sciences, is growing. The activity
of scientific research that is centered around the study of
chemical and biological processes in aquatic ecosystems or
not subject to heavy pollution such as lakes, rivers, wetlands
and ecosystems marins. His activity revolves around 4 main
themes:
The first deals with the dynamics of nutrients (C,
N, S, P, Si, I, Mn, Fe, Mo) or related to the biological productivity
of the ocean (Ba) in the water column and aquatic sediments.
Particular attention is paid to diagenesis (physico-chemical
and biological constituents of organic and mineral sediments).
The second study addresses the transfer of material
in the soil solution continuum, river and wetland and fate
of micropollutants such as heavy metals (Cd, Pb, Zn, and Cr).
The roles and functions of organic matter, mineral phases
and micro-organisms are studied in these two subjects because
they play a major role in the fate of these elements during
diagenesis and during their transfer to the biosphere.
Our third area of research is dedicated to
identifying the role of bacteria (eubacteria and arche) in
biogeochemical processes. It involves identifying metabolic
pathways, to understand the dynamics of substrates at stake
The fourth section covers the development of sensors for
data acquisition physico-chemical in situ at high spatial
and temporal resolution, in waters, soils and sediment. Understanding
the processes involved in the global carbon cycle and associated
trace elements is the common denominator of these four themes.
Therefore, the objective is a better scientific understanding
of surface processes and sub surface involved in environmental
issues. It is in this sense that the statement of the Academy of Sciences of the international symposium
posed the following questions:
How minerals are they actors of sustainable development?
How are they? How do they degrade? What do they maintain
trade with the living?
At this international conference, * the best
experts, French and foreign, will analyze the mineralogy,
a field that focuses on the solid earth (geosphere) in terms
of its relations with the hydrosphere (rivers and oceans )
and biosphere (life). At each of four sessions, two lights,
one on basic knowledge and experimental, the other on environmental
and societal implications, renew our vision of an inert minerals,
showing their close intertwining with the environment and
our technological choices. This modern concept of a mineral
dynamic, complex and reactive, based on the most recent instruments
of physics and chemistry, which dissect the minerals like
a "Meccano" in the community living in contact which
they are formed or degraded. One understands better and better
the role of soils as natural filters of our environment, and
as an irreplaceable reservoir of nutrients for plants. More
generally, mineralogical processes that play at the microscopic
level are generators of global issues, recent developments
in the Amazon to the impact of contaminants.
The introductory lecture will explain this recent concept of "environmental
sciences at the molecular level, based on numerous examples
in France and the United States (Gordon Brown and Georges Calas
Co-organizers of the conference).
Session I "mineral-solution interfaces: responsiveness
to pollution process" (Monday 10am-12.30pm), chaired
by Georges Pedro Academy of Sciences, will focus on interfaces,
which determine the formation of minerals. The process of
pollution or pollution of soils are governed by the release
or otherwise trapping heavy metals or arsenic (Laurent Charlet,
Guillaume Morin and Jerome Rose). A thorough knowledge of
the respective surfaces of minerals and bacteria facilitates
the direct approach interfaces (Fabien Thomas). We understand
now how minerals become less harmful in the deeper soil layers
(Ruben Kretzschmar).
Session II "Interaction between minerals and biological
activity" chaired by Gordon Brown of Stanford University (California) looks at relations micro-minerals.
We begin to realize the importance of the formation of bacterial
biofilms, ubiquitous in the precipitation of specific minerals
(David Vaughan). The nano-materials (oxides of titanium, for
example) for industrial products represent a new source of
disruption in our environmental monitoring (Jean-Yves Bottero).
When minerals are synthesized by microorganisms, their biological
origin is seen in texture and can thus date the first traces
of life on earth (Karim Benzerara).
The Roundtable, chaired by Jean-Pierre Jolivet (Université
Pierre et Marie Curie, Paris), will assess the relationships
between chemical processes and process mineralogy.
Session III "Minerals, witnessed the formation and evolution
of the soil", chaired by Adrian Herbillon (University of Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium), show the link between the wealth
of a ground and the nature of its minerals. The formation
and degradation of spectacular Amazonian soils represent a
textbook case of relations between the rivers and soil in
a symbolic environment (Emmanuel Fritsch). The crucial role
of clay minerals in soils will be specified (Sabine Petit).
The state of iron also affects the fertility of soils, as
illustrated by the extreme conditions, in reducing or oxidizing
podzols laterites in the Sahel (Joseph Stucki).
Session IV "Mineralogy and strategy for waste storage"
, chaired by George Calas (University Pierre and Marie Curie),
will address the resistance to weathering matrix storage of
nuclear waste. From their 2000 years, what information we
provide archaeological glasses (Libourel Guy)? The uranium
deposits are they good models for improving the safety of
storage sites for nuclear waste (Rodney Ewing)? What are the
alternatives to glass (Jean-Marc Montel)? Finally, we see
the processes involved in geological storage of atmospheric
CO2 (François Guyot).
The final round table , chaired by Jean Dercourt, Permanent
Secretary of the Academy of Sciences, will focus on knowledge transfer
from laboratory to field. How to move from atomic scale to
the landscape? How to project into the future, with time scales
of geological processes? How to use what is known about the
minerals to meet the challenges of our society: waste storage,
degradation or pollution of soil and water, and impacts of
mining and industrial development sustainable?
The
opening of the symposium will be made by Jean Dercourt,
Permanent Secretary of the Academy of Sciences, and then the
issue of environmental mineralogy: understanding the behavior
of elements chemicals in ecosystems: Environmental Mineralogy
, otherwise, Understanding Element Behavior in Ecosystems will be the subject
of analysis of Gordon E Brown
[4]
, Jr and Georges Calas
[5] the two scientists Gordon E. Brown, Jr [6] ., and Georges Calas [7]
think There is
growing recognition that minerals and the natural environment
are inextricably linked in a number of important ways. Environmental Mineralogy is rapidly expanding, integrating mineralogy
with life sciences and geochemistry in order to understand
interactions of the geosphere, hydrosphere, atmosphere, and
biosphere. Minerals comprise many of the key components of
our world, including soils and modern sediments, mineralized
parts of living organisms, atmospheric aerosols, building
materials such as cements, and many natural resources used
by modern civilization. Environmental Mineralogy is also concerned with major issues such as the remediation of contaminated
sites left by centuries of mining and industrial activities
and the rapid development of commerce, the interaction of
minerals with metal/metalloid contaminants, water, and biological
organisms in ecosystems, and the disposition of contained
nuclear and industrial waste. In addition, the development
of novel technologies, such as the use of engineered nanomaterials
as antibacterial agents, poses potential threats to human
health. To address such issues at a fundamental level requires
molecular-scale knowledge about biogeochemical processes at
mineral surfaces, the defective nature of minerals, the structural
chemistry of disordered materials (nanophases, glasses, gels,
metamict minerals) and aqueous solutions, and the speciation
of trace elements in minerals and solutions.
Although they are not usually considered part of "classical"
mineralogy, research in these non-classical areas is necessary
to provide a coherent view of the interplay between pollutant
release/sequestration/transport and the functioning of geochemical
and biogeochemical systems.
Environmental mineralogists have used a number of modern instrumental,
laboratory, and theoretical methods to define how contaminant
and pollutant atoms and molecules are associated with
minerals at the atomic level and how various geochemical and biological
processes affect their release into ecosystems. For example,
the intense light from synchrotron radiation sources is now
commonly used to determine how inorganic pollutants, such
as arsenite, are bonded to mineral surfaces under various
environmental conditions, to characterize the structure of
hydrated mineral surfaces to which pollutants are attached,
and to determine the alteration processes of minerals and
glasses. Such molecular-level studies are often coupled with
macroscopic studies of biogeochemical processes such as the
interaction of microbial organisms with heavy metal contaminants,
forming biominerals or transforming contaminants into more
or less toxic forms, the corrosion of waste matrices, the
behavior of nanominerals and mineral nanoparticles in different
environments, and the formation of soils. Because of their
high surface areas and enhanced chemical reactivities relative
to their macroscopic counterparts, natural nanoparticles can
play an especially important role in controlling the chemical
behavior and transport of inorganic pollutants in natural
waters and the atmosphere.
Our talks
will focus on (1) the environmental mineralogy and microbiology
of mercury in mining environments, (2) the nature and role
of ferrihydrite nanoparticles in acid mine drainage systems,
(3) the interaction of Pb(II) with Fe-oxide and Al-oxide surfaces,
(4) the environmental mineralogy and geochemistry of arsenic
in southeast Asia, (4) the role of Zr in the durability of
nuclear glasses, (5) the use of radiation-induced defects
of kaolinite in natural analogues and tropical soils, and
(6) element speciation in soils developed on geochemical anomalies.
[8]
The question of Reactivity at
mineral-water interfaces, redox processes and arsenic transport
in the environment was raised by Laurent Charlet
[9] Guillaume Morin [10]
Jérôme Rose
[11] as follows;
Massive deleterious
impacts to human health are resulting from the use of arsenic
bearing groundwaters in South-East Asia deltas and elsewhere
in the world for drinking, cooking and/or irrigation (Charlet
and Polya, 2006; Polya and Charlet, 2009). Unless a scientific
understanding of the redox mobilization/immobilization mechanisms
at work is achieved and comprehensive effective water treatment
measures are put in place, it is estimated that in Bangladesh alone, millions of people will
develop arsenicosis and excess deaths of several thousand
per year will result (Yu et al., 2003).
The fate of arsenic and other oxyanion forming metalloids (Se, Mo, P..) is controlled
in natural systems as well as in engineered systems, such
as modern water treatment plants, by Fe nanoparticles (Morin
and Calas 2006). Depending on redox potential, total sulfide
and carbonate content, different particles may constitute
the controlling reactive surface. In our three groups we have
investigated by XAFS spectroscopy, neutron diffraction, HRTEM
and DFT molecular modeling, the sorption of arsenic onto ferric
oxyhydroxides (Ona-Nguema te al. 2005), nano-maghemite (Auffan
et al., 2008; Morin et al. 2008), nanomagnetite (Yean et al.,
2005; Wang et al., 2008; Morin et al. 2009), iron hydroxycarbonates
(Ona-Nguema et al., 2009), mackinawite (Wolthers et al., 2005),
calcite (Roman-Ross et al., 2005) and gypsum (Fernandez- Martinez
et al., 2008). Arsenite forms a specific triple corner sharing
surface complex both with magnetite (Wang et al., 2008; Morin
et al. 2009) and maghemite (Auffan et al. 2008), which explains
in part the very high adsorption affinity of arsenite for
these substrates. In addition, a “nano” effect is best observed
for magnetite which may sorb 0.021, 0,388 and 1.532 mmol g-1
of arsenite, i.e. 5-6 Wmol m-2 to 18 Wmol m-2, when normalized
to specific surface area, for particle size decreasing from
200 nm to 20 and 12 nm (Yean et al, 2005 ; Auffan et al, 2007;
2009; Morin et al. 2009). The origin of this increased reactivity
is still a matter of debate, and could be due to increased
surface tension (Auffan et al. 2008, 2009) or to surface precipitation
of arsenite (Morin et al. 2009).. Polymeric arsenite surface
complexes may also form at the surface of greenrusts and may
play an important role in delaying the release of arsenic
in suboxic soils (Ona-Nguema et al. 2009; Wang et al. 2009).
While electron transfer between structural Fe(II) and arsenate
species is not observed on green-rusts (Wang et al. 2009),
arsenate may be reduced by Fe2+ sorbed on micas and clays
(Charlet et al., 2005). In case of carbonate and sulfate minerals,
the isomorphic substitution of the constitutive anion by the
appropriate arsenic oxyanion may enhance the sorption as well
(Roman-Ross et al., 2005; Fernandez-Matrinez ert al., 2008).
Within the complexity of delta hydrology and chemistry (Métral
et al., 2008) it appears that within hundred meters the predominant
nano mineral phase changes. These nanoparticle may induce
either the trapping of arsenic (by Fe(II/III) oxides and hydroxides
and carbonates) in suboxic environments where sandy soils
allow a direct vertical recharge of the groundwater, or its
mobilization to the groundwater when local impermeable soils
lead below in the aquifer to anoxia and where the dominant
nanophase (mackinawite) is a poor sorbent. Transition from
suboxia to anoxia is further controlled by microbial activity,
and the decoupling of Fe and As release is dictated by the
solubility of nano ferrihydrite (Burnol et al., 2007, Métral
et al., 2008) or of lepidocrocite (Ona-Nguema et al., 2009).
The specific reactivity of nanoparticles not only accounts
for the difference in As bioavailability within soils and
aquifers, but also open new avenues in water treatment and
green chemistry.( in Biblography)
The question of exploration of natural surfaces:
from minerals to biocolloïds was raised by Fabien Thomas,
Jérôme Duval, Laurent Michot, Frédéric Villiéras [12] as follows;
On the surface of the planet, the solid material is
transported by water, air, industry, and accumulated in soils
and sediments in a finely divided, often in the colloidal
domain. In these conditions, processes solid interfaces dominate
many environmental phenomena as changes in soil, transfer
of contaminants, the formation of biofilms. The last two decades
have seen an impressive development of methods analytical
local and global giving access to the physico-chemical properties
of these systems in different scales, and allowing a rigorous
study of the mechanisms at the interface solid-aqueous solution
of
scales ranging from angstroms to millimeters. With the results
of these methods, it is thus increasingly obvious that the
heterogeneous and evolutionary nature of natural particulate
matter can be taken into account for a rigorous understanding
of these processes. Their model is developed in the same direction.
Conventional models based on interfaces theories of Langmuir
/ Freundlich, Poisson / Boltzmann DLVO, Stumm / Healy, Van
Smoluchowski, being strictly valid only within a strict framework
- diagram of hard spheres and homogeneous
smooth - it is essential to adapt to local conditions of strong
natural interfaces. So heterogeneity of energy mineral surfaces
is quantified by the adsorption of inert gas probes (Ar),
polarizable (N2) or interactive (H2O) or aqueous ions, and
modeled by the convolution adsorption isotherms of local theory.
Regarding the biocolloïdes (bacteria, viruses, humic acids),
the concepts of interface, charge or surface potential must
be abandoned to those of interphase, filler density, permeability,
molecular configuration. The model must then be done by coupling
electrostatic and hydrodynamic fields, ionic transport and
intra / extra particle. Measures must also be diverse and
coupled: electrokinetic, potentiometric titration, diffusion
light correlation spectroscopy, fluorescence and AFM etc..
These fine knowledge of the solid-liquid interface are inserted
directly into the understanding mechanisms of self-association
of natural colloids including the dispersion of clay recentlydescribed
as liquid crystals or the formation of biofilms. They are
static (equilibrium thermodynamics) or dynamic (transport
coupling dynamic and kinetic reactions, chémodynamique ecosystems),
these studies open up a fieldnew multidisciplinary research
and to better understand the reactivity of the particles biological
/ environmental in the aqueous medium and thus processes such
as aggregation,
bioadhesion, fixing and bioavailability of toxic.
Before asking the question on the Sulfide formation
and trace metal mobility in floodplain soils he should
honor the ideas of Swiss scientists, Ruben Kretzschmar1, Frank-Andreas
Weber, Anke Hofacker, Ralf Kaegi, and Andreas Voegelin and
the answers given by Ruben Kretzschmar the five questions
on the science.
1 When did you decide to study soil science?
I first discovered my fascination for soils
during my undergraduate studies at the University Göttingen,
Germany, where I studied agricultural
sciences from 1983 to 1985. We had a truly excellent lecture
in introductory soil science including several exciting field
trips led by Prof. Brunk Meyer and his group. I was most fascinated
about the variability of soil properties in the landscape
and about how much information one can read from a soil profile,
if one understands the processes leading to its formation.
During my graduate studies at the University Hohenheim (1986-1989),
I developed a special interest in soil chemistry and soil-plant
interactions. I was also impressed and fascinated by the lectures
of Prof. Ernst Schlichting on tropical soils and by many excellent
field trips offered at Hohenheim, including a 2-week trip
through southern Spain with Prof. Karl Stahr. After
graduating in 1989, I decided to join the Ph.D. program of
the Department of Soil Science at North Carolina State University, USA.
2 Who has been your most influential teacher?
There is no short answer to this question,
because many different teachers and scientists have influenced
my academic development in different stages of my career.
My most influential teacher during my graduate studies was
Prof. Horst Marschner, who was my Diploma thesis advisor at
the University Hohenheim. During the time in his research
group I experienced for the first time what it means to be
a scientist. I studied the influence of Al-toxicity on growth
of pearl millet and other crops in acidic sandy soils of Niger, West Africa. I conducted growth experiments in soil and solution culture, collected and
analyzed soil solutions, measured root lengths, analyzed the
nutrient status of the plants, etc., and ended up with a large
data set to be interpreted. Horst Marschner was a great advisor
during this time, because he always listened to my thoughts
and gave inputs where needed. During the time at his institute,
I learned a lot about rhizosphere processes, plant nutrition,
soil-plant interactions, and about conducting research in
general. As a PhD student at North Carolina State University, my most influential teachers
were Profs. Wayne Robarge and Sterling Weed. Wayne Robarge taught me
many important concepts in soil physical chemistry, while
Sterling Weed was a great teacher in soil mineralogy. As a
postdoc at ETH Zurich, I further developed my understanding
of colloid and surface chemistry working with Profs. Hans
Sticher and Michal Borkovec.
3. What do you find most exciting about soil
science?
One of the most fascinating aspects about
soil science is that it is a truly interdisciplinary science.
One can study soils from the viewpoints of chemistry, mineralogy,
physics, biology, social sciences, or other disciplines. It’s
a universe of its own. Also, many soils contain highly valuable
information for archeologists, climatologists, and geoscientists.
Another exiting aspect about soil science is its importance
for nature and human life. Soils are one of the most important
and vulnerable natural resources on earth. Practically the
entire production of food and fiber depends on fertile soils.
Protecting soils from degradation by human activities and
global climate change will be one of the greatest challenges
in the near future. Soil science can make a big contribution
in this respect.
4. How would you stimulate teenagers and
young graduates to study soil science?
Students interested in the functioning, management
or use of ecosystems will be exposed to soil sciences at some
point of their curriculum. At ETH Zurich, my course in Pedosphere
is mandatory for BSc students in agronomy, forestry, environmental
sciences, environmental engineering, earth sciences and biology.
In this lecture course, I try to stimulate interest in soils
by explaining the role and functioning of soils in supporting
terrestrial life on earth. In the following year, we offer
a series of soil science field excursions and practical exercises.
Field courses are very important, because without them most
students perceive soil science as something very abstract.
It is important to experience soils in the field early on,
because then also the theory behind soil functioning becomes
more fascinating. That’s at least how it worked for me.
5. How do you see the future of soil science?
At the global scale, food production for
a growing population while preserving soil fertility and water
resources remains one of the most pressing problems of this
century. Soil scientists can make important contributions
in this field, both at the fundamental and applied level.
Soil science also has an important role in other environmental
issues, e.g., protecting biodiversity, predicting global element
cycles and the emission or absorption of trace gases relevant
for global climate change, improving hydrologic and climatic
models, or understanding and controlling the fate of organic
and inorganic pollutants in the environment. In all these
and other areas, fundamental and applied research on various
aspects of soils is essential. There are many exiting opportunities,
especially at the interfaces between soil science and other
scientific disciplines. Therefore, I think that soil science
does have a positive future. However, we need to convince
policy makers that soil science should be given a high priority
and that excellence in teaching and research in soil science
needs to be maintained.
Concerning the question of the
Sulfide formation and trace metal mobility in floodplain
soils exposed by Ruben Kretzschmar, Frank-Andreas Weber
Anke Hofacker Ralf Kaegi, and Andreas Voegelin
During the
past decades to centuries, many river floodplain soils in
Europe and other industrialized regions
of the world have served as sinks for inorganic and organic
contaminants released into rivers with urban wastewater and
runoff, industry, mining, and other human activities. Such
historically contaminated
floodplain soils may now release contaminants into rivers and groundwater, even
long after the original contamination sources have been remediated.
They therefore can pose a continued threat to water quality
and ecosystem health. Biogeochemical processes in floodplain
soils are highly dynamic, e.g., periodic
flooding and drainage induce pronounced soil reduction and oxidation cycles.
Our current research aims at a better understanding of the
speciation changes and mobility of trace metals and metalloids
during redox fluctuations in contaminated floodplain soils,
in order to improve predictions of contaminant mobility and
toxicity.
Different biogeochemical processes may lead to increasing
or decreasing trace metal mobility during prolonged soil flooding.
On one hand, reductive dissolution of iron and manganese oxyhydroxides
results in a loss of sorbent surfaces and increased concentrations
of dissolved Fe2+ and Mn2+ in solution, which may promote
the release of sorbed trace metals. Additionally, increasing
concentrations of dissolved organic carbon in pore water may
contribute to trace metal mobilization. On the other hand,
trace metals also may be immobilized as a result of rising
pH and by formation of poorly soluble sulfide minerals during
sulphate reduction. The potential for trace metal immobilization
by sulfate reduction, however, depends on the concentrations
of sulfide-forming trace metals and of available sulfate present
in the soil. The amount of sulfate in river floodplain soils
can become the limiting factor, in which case formation of
the most insoluble metal sulfides (e.g., CuS) may consume
all available sulfide, leaving other chalcophile metals in
more mobile forms. Furthermore, recent results have shown
that prolonged soil flooding may also lead to the formation
of sulfide nanoparticles and colloids in the pore water, which
may be mobile and thereby increase metal mobility. In this
presentation, our recent research on metal mobility in river
floodplain soils will be presented and discussed.
[15]
In light of the statement of Swiss scientists, we should
raise the issue of contamination of land south of Kurdistan
chemical where weapons were used by Saddam Hussein and chemical
findings on the health of our people, and use of biological
and bacteriological weapons by the armed forces of Turkey
and use of chemical and biological weapons against the combatants
of the Workers Party of Kurdistan and PhosfoR bombs thrown
by the Turkish army on our forests in northern Kurdistan and
know what is the Mineral-organic-microbe interfacial interactions:
environmental impacts from molecular to macroscopic scales
on Kurdistan, without forgetting the East Kurdistan side of
Persia and chemical weapons used by the reactionary Iranian
mullahs and scholars answer the following On this issue the
English scientist David J. Vaughan [16] thinks that
Human activities now have an unprecedented impact on the materials and processes
at or near the Earth’s surface, in the so-called ‘critical
zone’ which is essential to all life. Here, where the lithosphere,
hydrosphere, atmosphere and biosphere meet, processes at interfaces
play a key role on scales from molecular to global. A particularly
important interface is that where the mineral surface can
interact with organic molecules, biomolecules and microbes.
At this interface, microorganisms play a critical role in
promoting electron transfer (redox) reactions, which may lead
either to the solubilisation of minerals or to their precipitation.
Microorganisms also produce the extracellular polymeric substances
(‘biofilms’) that may coat mineral surfaces, or form in fractures
or the pore space of sediments, thus influencing reactivity
and fluid flow.
In this presentation, mineral-organic-microbe interactions will be considered,
particularly with regard to examples such as iron oxide mineral
surfaces and Fe(III) reduction. The overall controls exercised
by specific mineral substrates, the molecular scale mechanisms
which can involve compounds acting as electron shuttles, and
the further impact of microbial iron reduction processes on
the geochemical behaviour of a range of other elements will
be considered. The development, nature and importance of biofilms
will also be discussed, and their roles both in creating local environments to allow precipitation of dilute
dissolved impurities from circulating fluids, and in controlling
the flow of such fluids. Experimental studies of biofilms
will be described, ranging from imaging of interstitial and
simulated fracture-filling biofilms at the micron-scale, to
mesoscopic scale column experiments, and to macroscopic (field)
scale studies of the hydraulic conductivity of unconsolidated
sediments.
We know that
regulate development of nanotechnology requires evaluation
work particularly impacts on ecosystems. This work is still
underdeveloped in the world. At first it appears that properties
that play an important role towards the disturbance of biological
activity are strongly dependent on the size of the dispersed
nanoparticles in natural environments. These properties are
mineralogy (eg TiO2), the crystallinity and surface reactivity
which affect the toxicity or via the redox potential (Fe °),
or by the release of toxic cations (Cd, Zn), structural changes
Fe2O3, Fe3O4). and transport of contaminants proven (
The biological effects will then depend mainly the formation
of oxidizing species oxygen entrainant oxidative stress.
The answer does not always seem to be correlated to the surface
specific (CeO2). The dissolution of metal oxide nanoparticles
is causing significant toxicities on micro-organisms. Cations
from this solution (Zn, Cd, Ag) are known for their toxicity.
Of surface formulations may reduce or delay their dissolution
in aquatic environments. The silver nanoparticles a few nanometers
with a surface dominated by the faces (111)
penetrate within bacteria and react with sulfur and phosphorus.
In fact, questions concerning the role of size with respect
to the responsiveness are still wide open: - For example is
it that the appearance of catalytic properties interferes
with electron transfer in the respiratory chain?
- Is the production of oxidizing species depending on the
size of nanoparticles enhances DNA breaks?
Does the strong
increase of specific surface area below 30 nm can cause
inactivation of protein adsorption? Is there a relationship
between size and the inflammatory response and genotoxic?
Finally, if the studies focus on nanoparticles "laboratories",
nothing is yet known about nanoparticles from materials widely
available and are brought into contact with aqueous media
to deconstruct. This issue was raised at the Symposium of
the Academy of Sciences which was the subject of the
paper entitled Nanomaterials and nanoparticles:
Disturbance of biological activity in the environmental sphere,
it seems that the intervention of Jean-Yves Bottero; Jerome
Rose; Melanie Auffan; Celine Botta; Jerome Labille [17] ; Masion Armand, Antoine Thill [18] Laila Benameur , Alain Botta , Michel De Meo [19] ; Chaneac Corinne, Jean-Pierre Jolivet [20]
had opened a path for other researchers who worked
on Lake Van, and I thought the disappearance of Lake Ourmieh Eastern Kurdistan. Thus the
question Nanomaterials and nanoparticles: Disturbance of biological
activity in environmental setting was asked.
As the river valley sacred Munzur Lake Ourmieh von away with such a life in
Kurdistan millennium for a nation that
is not free. As my people under the bombardments of napalm
and chemical weapons and biological nature of my country has
been a cultural genocide ecological and archaeological heritage
of all mankind in our century and centuries of the future.
The ideas of scholars ed Academy of Sciences
for the sacred river of Munzur and will ask my questions and
I am informed this matter to the world public opinion and
lead scientists, academicians, scientists from all over the
world. Karim Benzerara, Georges Ona-Nguema, Jennyfer Miot,
Guillaume Morin [21]
who worked on Lake Van think, significance
mechanisms and environmental implications of microbial biomineralization
processes Microorganisms can form minerals and impact
subsequently the geochemical cycle of many different elements,
including pollutants. These biomineralization processes can
be indirectly triggered by the metabolic activity of
microorganisms and the resulting chemical shifts in their
surrounding microenvironments. Moreover, nucleation
and growth of mineral phases can be impacted by microbial
surfaces. Finally, biomineralization processes may sometimes
be genetically programmed. Although these questions
are ancient, we still poorly know the diversity, the significance
and the impact of the microbial mineralization processes
in the environment. The new tools that are now available in
the field of mineralogy, geochemistry and microbiology
however offer the opportunity to improve significantly our
understanding of these processes. Here, we will
present a combination of field and laboratory-based studies
illustrating how bacteria can form minerals. We will
first review the study case of the Carnoules acid mine drainage
(Gard, France) where microorganisms and associated
organic polymers have been shown to impact significantly the
sequestration of arsenic in sediments by forming biominerals.
Then, we will give an overview of the diversity of
biomineralization patterns that can be observed in the environment,
illustrating some of the mechanisms that are involved
in the precipitation of mineral phases by bacteria. This requires
the use of cutting-edge microscopy and spectroscopy
techniques which still need further improvements. Finally,
we will present the crucial information brought by
laboratory experiments focusing specifically on iron biomineralization
induced by Fe(II) bacterial oxidation at neutral pH under
anoxic conditions. In particular, we will show that in
some cases, biomineralization occurring at the contact of
microbial cells leads to their entombment in minerals
and thus fossilize them. This questions the impact of biomineralization
on the viability of microbes and the subsequent evolutionary
pressure that it might exert on microbes. Alternatively, it
forms nano to microscale objects that might be preserved
in the geological record opening promising perspectives for
the study of the history of life and biomineralization.
The question
of Crystal-chemistry of iron and aluminum in tropical
environments: formation and degradation of the soils
in the Amazon basin examined by Emmanuel Fritsch, Étienne
Balan [22]
By its surface, its location
in the tropics, its diverse coverage and alteration Considerable
quantities of materials exported to the ocean, the Amazon
Basin region is emblematic both from the perspective of understanding
the operation of the Geochemical Earth's surface, as in that
of sustainable development. The surveys undertaken in the
project Radambrasil (1978) showed that there was an orderly
distribution of soils across landscapes and also ordered distribution
of these landscapes across the basin. However, the mechanisms
and chronology of the process leading to the orderly distribution
remain poorly understood. To predict the evolution of Amazonian
soils, it is now essential to identify what processes are
still active today and linking process old archived in mineral
transformations geodynamic and paleoclimatic changes affecting
the basin as a whole. The structural and mineralogical studies
conducted on sites representative of major
environments hydro-bio-geochemistry of the basin have revealed
the major processes (laterization, waterlogging and podzolization)
have acted in different compartments of these landscapes.
In
compartments drained lateritic best, crystal-chemical study
of secondary minerals, mainly clays and iron oxides, can identify
multiple generations coexisting in the same profile, to determine
the physicochemical conditions prevailing during training,
and in some cases to prove their age. Expanding compartments
and hydromorphic podzol in these lateritic formations is attributed
to the more recent development of systems and groundwater
acidification. These processes operate predominantly in the
central and upstream basin, corresponding to the most rainy.
The remobilization of elements previously accumulated (mainly
Fe and Al) is particularly active in the weathering front
side located at the transition between soil compartments,
and indicates the topicality of the processes involved
This multiscale approach allows to situate the soil systems
studied in a more global geodynamics, assigned to the history
of the basin, and to better understand the place of tropical
systems in the evolution of continental surfaces.
The two scientists Sabine Petit, Dominique Righi
[23] believe that Significance and role of clays in soils:
use of recent experimental data, is very important and significant
in terms of scientific research In soils, the transfer elements
are controlled by reactions at the interfaces between mineral
constituents, organic and biological. The clay minerals by
their properties largely govern these reactions. With a cation
exchange capacity (CEC), they play an important role in controlling
the flow of cations. They also help neutralize the natural
acidification of soil saturation of CEC by the protons released
during the soil-plant interactions. However, it is shown experimentally
that by altering the H +-smectites are not stable and that
the pages whose interlayer spaces are more accessible are
selectively dissolved, the chemical composition of the octahedral
layer also involved. Thus, in soils moderately alkaline very
clay-rich smectites (Vertisols of Italy), detailed analysis
of the value and location of the charge sheet of the smectites
suggests a quick selection of minerals whose crystal chemistry
is the best adapted to the geochemical conditions prevailing
in the different soil horizons. While the CEC and expense
sheets available clays are identical, the location of charges
is different in different horizons. Only smectites at high
tetrahedral charges are present in the upper horizons.
Under
the conditions of soil montmorillonites (inherited from the
sediment) are unstable, they disappear in favor of beidellites
high load. The experiment confirms the preferential alteration
of dependent octahedral clays (montmorillonite). A "illitisation"
apparent is observed, caused by the binding of K and the irreversible
closure of part of the interlayer spaces of beidellites high
load. The impact on the behavior of these soils are important
because they progressively lose their ability to interchange.
Furthermore, to predict (or reconstruct) the functioning of
soil, it is appropriate to use the crystal-chemical characteristics
of clay minerals if at the same time, it captures their process
of formation and transformation. The relationship between
the crystal chemistry of clay minerals and their training
requirements are difficult to establish the study of natural
minerals, and speculative, because too many parameters involved
are crucial. In simple systems, the syntheses mineral can
specify how environmental conditions induce the formation
of minerals with crystal chemistry or crystallinity particular:
for example the negative effect of pH paper on the crystallinity
of kaolinite has been clearly demonstrated. By cons no link
could be observed between the iron content and structural
crystallinity of these minerals. Work in progress also emphasize
the role of pH in the crystal chemistry of smectites synthesized
especially in the Al-Fe system.
The Effects
of Iron Redox Cycles on Smectite Properties examined by Joseph
W. Stucki, [24] The oxidation state of structural Fe in expandable clay
minerals is known to assert a significant influence on the
chemical and physical properties of these ubiquitous soil
constituents. Because redox cycles in nature are common, the
current state of an Fe-bearing clay mineral in the soil is
determined by how it has responded to such cycles. In this
presentation the changes in chemical and physical properties
of smectite due to single and cyclic redox events will be
reviewed. Studies have shown that reduction of structural
Fe(III) to Fe(II) increases the cation fixation capacity of
smectite. If K+ is the exchanged cation, reoxidation only
partially reverses the fixation and some of the Fe(II) is
precluded from reoxidation. Further redox cycles continue
to increase the residual Fe(II) and fixed K+ in the reoxidized
state, giving the smectite an illitic character. Other changes
also occur within the 2:1 layer of the smectite that may be
irreversible, including partial dehydroxylation and solid-state
cation migration between cis- and trans-octahedral
sites. The reversibility of these changes depends on the extent
of reduction. Macroscopic properties affected include cation
exchange capacity, specific surface area, mineral solubility,
and swelling in water. Knowing the dependence of these chemical
and physical properties on redox cycles provides information
from which a more complete historical record of soil formation
can be constructed.
For Rodney C. Ewing,
[25] think that scientific thought and technical on The
“Back-End” of the Nuclear Fuel Cycle: Role of Mineralogy
for the Safe Management of Nuclear Waste is very
important. The disposal of fission products and actinides
generated by the “back-end” of the nuclear-fuel cycle is
one of the major challenges in environmental sciences for the 21st century.
Because some fission products (e.g., 99Tc, 129I, 79Se
and 135Cs) and actinides (e.g., 239Pu and 237Np) are
long-lived, they have a major impact on the risk assessments
of geological repositories for nuclear waste. Thus, demonstrable
long-term chemical, radiation and mechanical durability
are essential properties of waste forms for the immobilization
and disposal of radionuclides. Mineralogical and geological
studies, so called “natural analogue studies,” provide excellent
candidates for long-term immobilization and a unique database
that cannot be duplicated by a purely materials science approach.
This “mineralogical approach” is illustrated by a discussion
of pyrochlore as a phase for the incorporation of transuranium
elements into nuclear waste forms and inert matrix fuels.
Since the discovery of Pu in 1941, more than 1,800 metric tonnes of Pu, and
substantial quantities of the “minor” actinides, such as Np,
Am and Cm, have been generated in nuclear reactors. Some of
these transuranium elements can be a source of energy in fission
reactions (e.g., 239Pu), a source of fissile material for
nuclear weapons (e.g., 239Pu and 237Np), and of environmental
concern because of their longhalf lives and radiotoxicity
(e.g., 239Pu and 237Np). In fact, new strategies for the advanced
nuclear fuel cycle are, in part, motivated by an effort to
mitigate some of the challenges of the disposal of these longlived
actinides. There are two basic strategies for the disposition
of these elements: 1.) to “burn” or transmute the actinides
using nuclear reactors or accelerators; 2.) to “sequester”
the actinides in chemically durable, radiation-resistant materials
that are suitable for geologic disposal.
There has been substantial interest in the use actinide-bearing minerals, such
as isometric pyrochlore, A2B2O7 (A= rare earths; B = Ti, Zr,
Sn, Hf), for the incoropation of actinides, particularly plutonium,
into nuclear waste forms and inert matrix fuels. Systematic
studies of rare-earth pyrochlores have led to the discovery
that certain compositions (B = Zr, Hf) are stable to very
high doses of alpha-decay event damage. The radiation stability
of these compositions is closely related to the structural
distortions that occur for specific pyrochlore compositions
and the electronic structure of the B-site cation. Recent
developments in the understanding of the properties of heavy
element solids have opened up new possibilities for the design
of advanced nuclear fuels and waste forms.
Role of mineralogical processes
in the geological CO2 storage exposed by François Guyot, [26] A large scale geochemical cycles, the earth's
atmospheric CO2, continuously produced by internal geological
activity is naturally stored mainly in the form of carbonate
minerals: silicate weathering by water acidified by CO2 leads
to the formation of ions that precipitate when saturation
with respect to the solid is reached. The solid carbonates
thus formed are then integrated into a geological cycle length
and remain stable for several tens of millions of years, making
the mechanism attractive for permanent sequestration of CO2
excess. However, the scale of the injection and geological
storage of CO2 envisaged in the coming decades in different
tanks to mitigate the environmental impact of the anthropogenic
increase of atmospheric CO2, the intrinsic kinetics of silicate
weathering and in some cases the precipitation of carbonates,
making these incremental process. This difference strongly
affects the perception of the reliability of this future technology:
mineralogy therefore exerts an important mechanistic control
on this very current environmental issue. The mineralogical
factors kinetics of dissolution of silicate and carbonate
precipitation, studied in the laboratory by several groups,
particularly in France (Grenoble, Montpellier, Nancy, Paris, Toulouse, non-exhaustive list) are presented
and the dissolution of silicates is generally identified as
the major limiting step. We show that this limitation is related
to the development of amorphous silicon layers more or less
passive on the surface of silicates, the question of predicting
the degree of passivation in a given condition, due to impurities
in the layer which alters the microstructure, Left wide open.
During the dissolution process, the deviation from equilibrium
thermodynamics has a significant effect on the structure of
the surface of minerals, and thus their dissolution kinetics,
an effect that is just beginning to be examined carefully
by using new methods records available, in particular the
coupling between Focused ion beam (FIB) electron microscopy
and analytical transmission. In some cases, the kinetics of
precipitation of carbonates in turn can become the limiting
factor of the process, mainly formed when minerals are dolomite,
ankerite, magnesite or siderite. From this perspective, the
process of biomineralization in the biosphere groundwater,
initially present at sites of geological storage or imported,
may play an important role and are just beginning to be discovered
and studied. Examples of research on these problems will be
presented.
Dr Ali KILIC, Paris,
14 09-2009
BIBLIOGRAPHY
ACADÉMIE DES SCIENCES, INSTITUT DE FRANCE
14-15 septembre 2009 Grande salle
des séances, Institut de France, 23 quai Conti, 75006 Paris.
2-School of Earth Sciences, Stanford University (USA)
3-, Institut de Physique du Globe de Paris, Université
Paris 6 et Institut de Minéralogie et de Physique des Milieux
Condensés, Université
Paris 7, Paris.
4-Surface & Aqueous Geochemistry
Group, Department of Geological and Environmental Sciences,
and Department of Photon Science and Stanford Synchrotron
Radiation Lightsource, Stanford University, Stanford, California
94305-2115, USA. gordon.brown@stanford.edu
Institut de Minéralogie et de Physique
des Milieux Condensés (IMPMC), Université Paris 6; Université
Paris 7; IPGP; CNRS; 140, rue de Lourmel, 75015 Paris, France.
5-Institut de Minéralogie et de Physique
des Milieux Condensés (IMPMC), Université Paris 6; UniversitéParis
7; IPGP; CNRS; 140, rue de Lourmel, 75015 Paris, France.
Auffan M, Rose J., Bottero J-Y.,
Lowry G.V, Jolivet J-P., Wiesner M.R., (2009) ‘Towards a definition of
nanoparticles based on novel size-dependent
properties’, Nature Nanotechnology, sous-presse.
Auffan M., Rose J., Proux O., Borschneck
D., Masion A., Chaurand P., Hazemann J. L., Chaneac C., Jolivet J.
P., Wiesner M. R., VanGeen A.,
Bottero, J. Y., (2008) ‘Enhanced adsorption of arsenic onto
nanomaghemites: As(III) as a probe of the surface structure’.
Langmuir, 24, 7, 3215-3222.
Auffan M., Shipley H.J., Yean S.,
Kan A.T., Tomson M., Rose J., Bottero
J-Y., (2007) ‘Nanomaterials as Adsorbant’ in ‘Environmental Nanotechnology:
Applications and Impacts of Nanomaterials’ (Mc
Graw Hill, Wiesner and Bottero
Ed.).
Burnol, A., Garrido, F., Joulian,
C., Dictor M.C., Bodenan, F., Baranger, P., Morin, G. Charlet
L. (2007)
Release of sorbed arsenic decoupled
from bacterial reduction of ferrihydrite: a biogeochemical
model. Geochemical Transactions,
8:12.
Charlet L.,
Chakraborty S., Varma S., Tournassat C., Wolthers M., Chatterjee
D. Roman Ross G. (2005)
Adsorption and heterogeneous reduction
of arsenic at the phyllosilicate-water interface. Advances
in Arsenic Research: Integration
of Experimental and Observational Studies and Implications
for
Mitigation, ACS Symposium, Series
Vol. 915, American Chemical Society, Editors: Peggy A. O’Day,
Dimitrios Vlassopoulos, Xiaoguang Meng, Liane G. Benning pp.41-59.
Charlet, L. and Polya, D. (2006)
Arsenic in Shallow, Reducing Groundwaters in Southern Asia: An
Environmental Health Disaster.
Elements 2:91-96.
Fernandez-Martinez, A., Cuello,
G.J., Johnson, M.R., Bardelli, F., Román-Ross, G.,. Charlet,
L., Turillas, X
(2008) Arsenate incorporation in
gypsum probed by X-Ray scattering, neutron diffraction, Density
Function Theory modeling. J. Phys.
Chem. A 112, 5159–5166.
Métral, J., Charlet, L., Bureau,
S., Basu Mallik, S., Chakraborty, S., M Ahmed K., Rahman,
MW, Cheng, Z. van Geen, A. 2008 Comparison of dissolved and particulate arsenic
distributions in shallow
aquifers of Chakdaha, India, and Araihazar, Bangladesh Geochemical Transactions 2008,
9:1-!8
Polya, D. and L. Charlet (2009)
Increasing Arsenic Risk? Nature Geoscience 2:383-394.
Morin G. and Calas G. (2006) Arsenic
in soils, mine tailings, and former industrial sites. Elements
2 (2), 97-
101.
Morin G., Ona-Nguema G., Wang Y.
Menguy N., Juillot F., Proux O., Guyot F., Calas G., Brown
JR. G.E. (2008) EXAFS analysis of arsenite and arsenate adsorption on maghemite.
Environmental Science
and Technology 42, 2361-2366.
Morin G., Wang Y., Ona-Nguema G.,
Juillot F., Calas G., Menguy M., Aubry E., Bargar J.R., Brown
Jr. G.E.
(2009) EXAFS and HRTEM Evidence
for As(III)-Containing Surface Precipitates on
Nanocrystalline Magnetite: Implications
for As Sequestration. Langmuir 25, 9119-9128.
Ona-Nguema G., Morin G., Juillot
F., Brown JR. G.E., Calas G. (2005) EXAFS analysis of Arsenic(III)
sorption onto 2-line ferrihydrite,
hematite, goethite, and lepidocrocite under anoxic conditions.
Environmental Science and Technology
39, 9147-9155.
Ona-Nguema G., Morin G., Wang Y.,
Menguy N., Juillot F., Olivi L., Aquilanti G., Abdelmoula
M., Ruby C.,
Bargar J.R., Guyot F., Calas G.,
Brown Jr. G.E. (2009) Arsenite sequestration at the surface
of
nano-Fe(OH)2, ferrous-carbonate
hydroxide, and green-rust after bioreduction of arsenic-sorbed
lepidocrocite by Shewanella
putrefaciens. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 73, 1359-1381.
Roman-Ross, G., Cuello, G.J., Turrillas,
X., Fernandez-Martınez, A., Charlet, L. (2006) Arsenite
sorption and
co-precipitation with calcite Chemical
Geology 233: 328-336.
Wang Y., Morin G., Ona-Nguema G.,
Menguy N., Juillot F., Aubry E., Guyot F., Calas G., Brown
JR. G.E. (2008)
Arsenite sorption at the magnetite-water
interface during aqueous precipitation of
magnetite. EXAFS evidence of a
new surface complex. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 72, 2573-2586.
Wang Y., Morin G., Ona-Nguema G.,
Juillot F., Aubry E., Guyot F., Calas G., Brown JR. G.E.
(2009) Evidence for different surface speciation of arsenite
and arsenate on green rust: an EXAFS and XANES
study. Environmental Science
and Technology, under review.
Wolthers M., Charlet L., Van der
Weijden C.H., Van der Linde P.R., Rickard D. (2005)
Arsenic mobility in the ambient
sulphidic environment: sorption of Arsenic (V) and Arsenic
(III) onto disordered mackinawite Geochim. Cosmochim Acta
69 (14): 3483-3492.
Yean, S., et al. (2005) Effect
of magnetic particle size on adsorption and desorption of
arsenite and arsenate. J. Matter. Res, 20:3255–3264.
Yu W.H., Harvey C.M. and Harvey
C.F. (2003) Arsenic in groundwater in Bangladesh: A geostatistical and epidemiological
framework for evaluating health effects and potential remedies.
Water
Resources Research 39: article number 1146.
Weber, F.-A., Voegelin, A., Kaegi, R., and Kretzschmar, R. (2009): Contaminant
mobilization by metallic
copper and metal sulphide colloids
in flooded soil. Nature Geoscience 2: 267 - 271.
Weber, F.-A., Voegelin, A., and
Kretzschmar, R. (2009): Multi-metal contaminant dynamics in
temporarily
flooded soil
under sulfate limitation. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 73: 5513-5527.
David J. VaughanUniversity of Manchester, Williamson Research Centre for
Molecular Environmental Science, and School of Earth, Atmospheric and Environmental
Sciences, Manchester, Royaume-Uni
ACADÉMIE DES SCIENCES, INSTITUT
DE FRANCE
14-15 septembre 2009 Grande salle des
séances, Institut de France, 23 quai Conti, 75006 Paris.
) This mystery is the transformation,
at the consecration of the host, the bread and wine into
body and blood of Christ.
School of Earth Sciences, Stanford University (USA)
, Institut de Physique du Globe
de Paris, Université Paris 6 et Institut de Minéralogie
et de Physique des Milieux Condensés, Université, Paris
7, Paris.
Surface &
Aqueous Geochemistry Group, Department of Geological and
Environmental Sciences, and
Department of Photon Science and
Stanford Synchrotron Radiation Lightsource, Stanford University,
Stanford, California 94305-2115, USA.
gordon.brown@stanford.edu
Institut de Minéralogie et de Physique
des Milieux Condensés (IMPMC), Université Paris 6; Université
Paris 7; IPGP; CNRS; 140, rue de Lourmel,
75015 Paris, France.
Institut de Minéralogie et de Physique
des Milieux Condensés (IMPMC), Université Paris 6; Université
Paris 7; IPGP; CNRS; 140, rue de Lourmel,
75015 Paris, France.
& Aqueous Geochemistry Group,
Department of Geological and Environmental Sciences, and
Department of Photon Science and
Stanford Synchrotron Radiation Lightsource, Stanford University,
Stanford, California 94305-2115, USA.
gordon.brown@stanford.edu
2 Institut de Minéralogie et de Physique
des Milieux Condensés (IMPMC), Université Paris 6; Université
LGIT, University of Grenoble I and CNRS, PO Box 53, F38041, Grenoble charlet38@gmail.com
IMPMC Universités Paris 6 et 7et CNRS,
140 r. Lormel, 75015 Paris guillaume.morin@impmc.jussieu.fr
Laboratoire Environnement et Minéralurgie,
UMR 7569 CNRS / Nancy-Université
BP
40 – 54501 Vandoeuvre-lès-Nancy Cedex
Institute of Biogeochemistry and Pollutant
Dynamics, ETH Zurich, CHN F23.1, 8092 Zurich, Switzerland.
Eawag, Swiss Federal Institute
of Aquatic Science and Technology, Ueberlandstrasse 133,
8600
Duebendorf, Switzerland
References: Weber, F.-A., Voegelin, A., Kaegi, R., and Kretzschmar, R.
(2009): Contaminant mobilization by metallic
copper and metal sulphide colloids
in flooded soil. Nature Geoscience 2: 267 - 271.
Weber, F.-A., Voegelin, A., and
Kretzschmar, R. (2009): Multi-metal contaminant dynamics
in temporarily
flooded soil
under sulfate limitation. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 73: 5513-5527.
David J. VaughanUniversity of Manchester, Williamson Research Centre for
Molecular Environmental Science, and School of Earth, Atmospheric and Environmental
Sciences, Manchester, Royaume-Uni
Aix-Marseille Université,
CEREGE, UMR 6635- CNRS, Europôle de l’Arbois, BP 80, 13545
Aix-en-Provence
cedex 4
CEA SaclayDSM/IRAMIS/SIS2M,
LIONS, 91191 Gif-sur-Yvette
LBME- Aix-Marseille
Université, UFR Médecine 27, bd Jean Moulin, 13385 Marseille
Cedex 5
Institut de Minéralogie
et de Physique des Milieux Condensés, UMR 7590, Université
Paris 6, IPGP & CNRS,140 Rue de Lourmel, 75015 Paris.
Institut de minéralogie et de physique des milieux condensés (IMPMC),
Paris
Sabine Petit, Dominique Righi, Université
de Poitiers, Laboratoire HydrASA, Poitiers
University of Illinois, Department
of Natural Resources and Environmental Sciences, Urbana, USA
University of Michigan, Geological
Sciences, Materials Science & Engineering, Nuclear Engineering
&Radiological Sciences, Ann Arbor, Etats-Un
François Guyot, Université Pierre et Marie Curie,
Institut de minéralogie et de physique des milieux condensés
(IMPMC), Paris
|